NYX Gel Liner and Smudger

I got NYX's gel liner and smudger in black, hoping to find a dupe of Stila's Smudge Pot. It turns out, I found something much better! While the Stila product didn't stay on very well throughout the day, the NYX liner did quite well. In fact, it stayed on just as well as my L'Oreal liner does. The NYX product was very highly pigmented, and went on very smoothly. It looked good smudged, and held it's position on my lid, even after I smeared it. If you're looking for a good one-product smoky look, this is definitely a good product to try, and I will definitely buy this liner again.