ELF Waterproof Eyeliner Pen

After being disappointed by previous eyeliner pens, especiallyHard Candy's , I decided to try ELF's Waterproof Eyeliner Pen. I bought it at Target, and put it on the next day. It ended up being just as bad as other eyeliner pens. Despite putting on coat after coat, the liner was still translucent. The eyeliner settled into my eyelids, and did not blend well with my eye shadow. I was really disappointed by this product; I would have expected ELF to do a little better job on it.