Hard Candy Stroke of Gorgeous Liquid Eyeliner

I bought Hard Candy's Stroke of Gorgeous Liquid Eyeliner after being impressed by their poppin' pigments. I ended up not liking the eyeliner, though. It went on really light, and barely had any pigment. The brush pulled at my skin a little, and the result of my first swipe was a jagged, barely visible line. I put on a few more coats, and by the time I was done, the line was at least even, but the liner, which was supposed to be black, showed up pale gray. What a disappointment; I won't buy this eyeliner again.